Last year’s crosstown series between the Cubs and White Sox was by far the worst in history. There’s no doubt about it. It also had the least buzz of any “Red Line Series,” “Windy City Classic” or whatever you want to call this overrated circus sideshow. However, this year Chicago takes on a level of apathy for the crosstown series.
If it weren’t for the fine folks at Comcast SportsNet Chicago, and their press release highlighting their crosstown series coverage, I wouldn’t even know that it was starting tomorrow night. Most Chicagoans don’t know it’s this week either. Because they don’t care.
Nor should they.
Now I feel bad for some of the good people over at CSN Chicago. This series is going to do terrible ratings. But don’t feel too bad for them for too long. In addition to being partially owned by the Cubs and White Sox, CSN Chicago is also partially owned by the Blackhawks. Which is topic 1a) in Chicago Sports right now. Top 1b) is the NFL Draft, and that’s why this year’s crosstown series will go more overlooked than it’s ever been.
This is the first year it falls at the same time as the NFL Draft. And since America cares ten zillions times more about the NFL Draft than it really should, and Chicago cares ten zillion times more about the Bears than they really should, and the Hawks are starting to peak at just the right time in the postseason…the second city is going to give one big DOOOOOONNNNNN’T CAAAAAARRRRREEEE to the crosstown series.
And there’s actually a lot of good that can come from crosstown series apathy. I’ll explain:
1. Diminished attention on hackneyed, shopworn storylines
This rivalry isn’t real. It’s media driven. And as the crosstown series has been in existence every year since 1997, so we’ve heard the same cliched stories every year for the past 17 years.
-Pairing up 1 Cubs and 1 Sox fan together for a ZANY SEGMENT! (sometimes it’s a trivia contest, sometimes it’s a FAN-OFF!)
-House divided (OMG! A Sox fan is married/engaged/dating a Cubs fan!!! How DRAMATIC!! How do they coexist???) Good God local television news is just so AWFUL
-lists of players and managers who’ve been on both sides (yawn. been there. done that.)
-Fan stereotypes You’ve heard these incessantly. Cub fans are, as the myth goes: Frat bros, Lincoln Park Trixies, North Shore trust fund babies, raging alcoholics and other ne’er do wells who attend the games only to mingle. The reality? Cub fans are some of the most dedicated and baseball knowledgeable around. There are Cub fans with unrivaled passion for their team and the baseball acumen of your most wonky sabermetricians.
White Sox fans are, as the myth goes: white trash, mulleted, criminal behavior, jumping on the field and destroy things etc. Yes, the Chicago baseball narrative of misnomers is dominated by class warfare. The reality?
The western suburbs, especially so in the Hinsdale and Naperville school districts, is some of Chicagoland’s most affluent areas. And those rich, elite Western burbs are hard core Sox country. Actual surveys and studies have shown the difference in income between Cubs and Sox fans is actually quite minimal. So we can put these myths to bed.
And overall, the less we in the media hype up the crosstown series, the less we’ll hear of these tired and predictable story lines.
2. This series doesn’t have a name. And it doesn’t really need one.
Cubs versus White Sox has been known as: crosstown series, crosstown cup, BP Crosstown Cup, BP Cup, #BECAUSEITSTHECUP, Windy City Classic, Windy City Series, Red Line Series…pick a name already!
BP brought me on to work with them on marketing and publicizing the series back in 2011. I worked as hard as possible, but I kept telling them that no one ever will call it the BP Cup or the BP Crosstown Cup…unless they’re being ironic.
Just forget about trying to brand and market this thing.
3. There are true rivals
The Cubs have the Cardinals and the Sox have the Twins. That’s rivalry enough.
The actual baseball within this collection of bread and circuses known as the crosstown series peaked in 2008 when both teams were in first place, and both teams went to the playoffs….and combined to win one total postseason game. Still, those days are not coming back any time soon.
The baseball this year will be better than last year, as the Sox are at least competitive and mediocre. And Jose Abreu is a difference maker. But the level of interest will be worse than 2013 because, the Cubs are the third worst team in baseball and the White Sox have baseball’s second worst attendance. Right now, the Fire are drawing about as many people.
Paul M. Banks owns The Sports Bank.net, an affiliate of Fox Sports. He’s also a frequent guest on national talk radio. Banks is a former contributor to NBC Chicago and the Washington Times, who’s been featured on the History Channel. President Obama follows him on Twitter (@paulmbanks)






