The Sox Exchange



Your Best in the Midwest Chicago White Sox Week in Review

By Soxman and Paul M. Banks

(SM) Well the All-Star break is over and the White Sox came out of the gate swinging, taking two of three from the Baltimore Orioles this past weekend and creeping up in the standings.  While the Sox appeared to have paid their “power” bill in the HR department, our pitching -specifically our bullpen- looked vulnerable.  While the Orioles are last in the AL East standings, they are 4th in the American League in team batting average, so by no means were they a push over opponent.  While I would have liked to see a sweep, I think taking two of three was acceptable.  Your thoughts?

(PMB) Agreed. Some of the Sox’s biggest collapses in recent history have come against Baltimore so any time they can win a series over the O’s, it’s nice. And being in the bottom of the AL East, isn’t as bad as it sounds. The AL East is by far the most powerful division in baseball and reminiscent of the AL Eastern Division of the 1980s when you had Detroit, Baltimore, New York, Boston and sometimes Toronto all being powerhouses at the same time. Back to today, now that the first half is over, time for Sox midterms: I’d give the season a B- overall, with a B+ for pitching, and a C- for fielding.

(SM) Let’s talk about the bullpen for a minute.  Bobby Jenks has 9.00 ERA in his last four appearances and has looked very hittable. Scott Linebrink has a 6.00 ERA in his last four games, and Matt Thornton has a 5.40 ERA in his last 8 games, most of which came from his meltdown on Saturday.  DJ Carrasco has a 6.52 ERA in his last five appearances, Aaron Poreda a 5.40 ERA in his last four appearance, Tony Pena has been just awful posting an 11.81 ERA since joining the White Sox.  While I know ERA spikes and dips tend to be extreme for relievers based on the small number of innings pitched, it appears in the last month our entire bullpen has hit a spike.  Should we be at all concerned?

(PMB) Not really. Baseball is a game where eventually you’ll have statistical progression/regression back towards the norm every season. Numbers and stats even out over time and normalize. The teams with the high payrolls will eventually get the production they paid for. Slumps happen and multiple hitters can enter slumps at the same time just like multiple pitchers, but no one slumps all season. Everyone was concerned (deservedly so) about the hitters finally warming up once the weather did and the fact that the Cell is such a launching pad, watching the power numbers take off. Well done and done, except most people forgot the basic obvious truth: when opposing pitchers ERAs take off, so will the Sox pitchers. That’s what I think is truly at work here- nothing more.

(SM) As the July 31st trade deadline approaches, things have been pretty quiet on the White Sox trade rumor front.  I’m sure Kenny Williams would have liked to have Carlos Quentin back for a week or two before evaluating the true needs of this team.  Do you see any moves that honestly make sense for the White Sox?  If there were one or two players whose performance will make or break the Sox chances, who are they and why?

For me, it’s Scott Podsednik and Jose Contreras.  Both of their “returns” have been a big part of the reason the Sox have climbed back into the division race.  Pods has been slumping in his last 35 ABs hitting just .229.  However his overall on-base percentage still stands at .361, 22 points higher than his career average.  He needs to keep getting on-base and getting into the heads of opposing pitchers.  Contreras had a rough outing Sunday, but has still been very effective, bringing his season ERA (4.75), closer in line with his career ERA (4.58).

(PMB) I’ve said it since March and I’ll say it again, the key to this season will be Gavin Floyd and John Danks, if they’re on then so is most of the starting rotation and therefore, the Sox have a chance to win most of their games down the stretch. Then it’s just a question of timely hitting and the bullpen doing its job. I’d really like to see Kenny go after a bat instead of an arm though. I wouldn’t mind another left-handed hitter in the lineup.

Good call on Contreras and Pods, I’d like to say that both are Comeback Player of the Year Candidates, but Jose has not really come back from anything expect just sucking royally. If Scotty truly stays healthy to the end of the season and finishes above .280 BA and .350 BA for the season, I’ll never doubt Kenny Williams again, because that pickup will be to this season what Carlos Quentin was to last year.quentin

(SM) Before we close with maybe or mirage, what do you think will be the White Sox keys to success in the second half of the season?  This is a very winnable division, but our second half schedule frightens me.  With home and away series against the Angels, Rays, Red Sox, and the Yankees, this is truly going to be a fight for the Sox, where they will need to take every series from beatable opponents.

(PMB) Yes, but every time I look at the schedule and do an assessment of what’s going to happen- it’s always all wrong. This team doesn’t seem to do that. I thought they could easily could have been in first place BEFORE the All-Star break, but of course things didn’t play out the way I envisioned. Perfect case in point for how this season has gone: losing a series at home to last place Cleveland then beating the best team in baseball (L.A. Dodgers two out of three). Of course, this is a very winnable division, but another “3 and out” (ok, four and out, unlike the Cubs we actually won one game) does nothing for me. at all. But who knows maybe this year’s postseason will be like the ’06 Cardinals where an 83 win team takes the flag.

(SM) Alright, let’s blare POD’s, “BOOM” as we go to our “closer” feature:  “Maybe or Mirage,” where we hit 5 quick points on the White Sox and offer our opinion whether it is a sign of things to come or something likely to fade quickly.  Remember, no answer can be longer than 20 words!  Let’s play ball…

Carlos Quentin will not amass 400 ABs in 2009.

(SM) Maybe.  He’s always been an injury prone player and plantar fascitis really never heals.

(PMB) Maybe. So much for that “steal” or “bargain deal” Kenny made to acquire him last year.

The Sox will not make a significant trade before the trade deadline.soxmansoxybacks

(SM) Maybe.  There’s no way the Sox give up Danks and Alexei for Doc Halladay.

(PMB) Maybe. How about acquiring a bat instead? We need that more.

Aaron Poreda will be a starter before the end of 2009.

(SM) Mirage.  He’s been effective in his role and sweaty Freddy is nearing a rehab assignment.

(PMB) Mirage. He’d have to leapfrog at least two or three people.

Gordon Beckham will have more RBIs than Carlos Quentin at the end of 2009.

(SM) Maybe.  Bacon has 22 and Carlos has 20 and a bad foot, shoulder, and wrist.

(PMB) Mirage. When CQ comes back, whenever that is, he hits at spot in the batting order more conducive to driving in runs.

Soxman will get killed at the Metrodome on July 29th.

(SM) Mirage.  I’m wearing my piranha proof Sox suit.

(PMB) Maybe. Best of luck to you my man, you’re quite brave!

Powered by


  1. paulmbanks says

    Gavin had his straight-change working tonight..if he keeps that up, it’s going to be a big factor towards a happy ending in Spet

  2. Monica All night Long says

    I love he sox exchange and the mass e-mail Soxman sent announcing you guys are back. Three things:

    1) Soxman said he wil soon be on Twitter. How do you sign up for his stuff and honestly what is Twitter?

    2) Disagree with Paul Banks in this exchange on a few points. The bullpen including Jenks (again) scared me yesterday, Jose totally blew out his achilles tendon. Many thought he might not pitch again. That’s comeback worthy.

    3) Is soxman really going to the Dome next week? Talk about a gazzelle walking into the lions dens.

  3. Have to agree with Monica. Jose’s injury was pretty serious and ended his 2008 season.

    Soxman you have bigger stones than Mt. Rushmore if you go to the dome to back our boys.

    Also any pics of you from mullet night? Heard you looked like kiss

  4. Soxman Stalker says

    Soxman I loved your mullet look on Friday! You are always very cordial and polite while projecting a positive image for kids not hanging on ballpark floozies and shying off from them when they try to give you attention.

    Plus you guys rock on these exchanges. I think you are right Soxman, Jenks appears to have been struggling a bit since the Twins series.

    Heard on the Score yesterday Kenny still may trade Dye!

    BE SAFE IN MN!!! Bring soxgirl or Batboy with you to be safe!!!

    LOVE YA SOXMAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  5. Mary, Mary says

    You guys are a great writing duo. It appears the sportbank and Red Eye are the only two places Soxman posts with any regularity as of late.

    I think there is really no right answer to the keys to the sox success. You could argue anyone because there are really that many questions.

    I was happy to see Brian Anderson FINALLY get sent down, even though I think he is better on defense than D Wise.

  6. Jeremiah D. says

    Great post. Carlos Quentin will define the Sox success.

    Can’t believe you are really going to the dome?

    Brave! A true grinder.

  7. Soxy Mama says

    Soxman- every day I get a Red Eye before getting on the train and immediately turn to the sports section to see if you are there.

    I love your weekly exchanges, but I’d like to make a request. Can you guys post on a specific day of the week? Its like wondering when are they gonna post?

    Great work as always. Paul are you going to be sports ace and attend a game with the soxman his year again?

    Great work guys and good luck at the Dome soxman!

  8. The Joker says

    Why So Serious? The Soxman–The Southside Dark Knight commeth to my home? We will be waking with a suprise or two….hero.

  9. Soxman eats twinkies for breakfast Joker!

    Great exchange guys as always. I like Pauls ideas about getting another left handed bat but who?

    A couple things to consider from go no where teams…

    Aubrey Huff- He bats lefty and could play first and third the OF. Could replace Josh Fields. He’s hitting 257 with 11 bombs.

    Brian Roberts- FA next year, perhaps he asking price has come down?

    Chase Headley- The Padres lost super prospect. Can play 3B, LF, RF. Maybe an over-hyped prospect for prospect–ala Brian Anderson for Headley?

  10. Soxman you are awesome!

  11. Love it guys!

  12. Tommy Tutone says

    Awesome work.

  13. Mullet Kelly says

    Soxman it was great seeing you at mullet night. Batboy as well although I must admit he looked aweful. The beard and just plain tired.

    Sox Girl was like going young… bring her back! LOL

    Still love ya Batboy but you might need some extended spring training in your first game back.

  14. Soxy Sheri says

    Sox Girl was pretty cute with Soxman and it represented female Sox super heroes…LOL.

    So glad Brian Anderson is gone. Sick of the he’s so great hype.

  15. Great work guys. I always look forward to your Sox discussion. You should both do a radio blog or something. Would love to see if the chemistry carries on the air.

  16. Awesome read guys. I love it. It really is hard to pinpoint the point of failure for this team if it does happen as there are so many possibilities.

    Any chance JD returns in 2010?

    Peace Soxman love seing you at the Cell.

  17. Soxman and Banksman…LOL. Great Sox update. I think Soxman may have been onto something in terms of concern with the bullpen. Linebrink and Jenks both had the golden horseshoe up their tales once again.

    Soxman you were awesome with the kids at the park on Friday at mullet night. We were in section 147 and could not help but notice the extra attention you paid to the child with down syndrome.

    Anyone who thinks you do what you do for women and fortune need only see that. High five buddy.

  18. Sox it 2 Me says

    When it comes to Sox talk you guys blow away Bores and Bernstien, Mulley and Hanley, the Afternoon saloon or even Bruce Levine because you go deeper offer stats plus a fan’s passion.

    No one better reflects passion than Soxman.

    I disagree with you guys one point.

    Defense will define the Sox success. You can only dodge a bullet so long.

    Go Sox!

  19. Have to admit, while Batboy is great, it does not look like his heart was in it Friday. When will Sox Girl be at another game? She seemed super thrilled to be at your side. In more ways than one Soxman? :)

    Soxman I wanted to offer you a personal congrats. On Friday you had a couple drunken ladies chasing you down for a photo as you seemed to fly through the outfield.

    As Batboy stopped for photos with them and you signed an autograph, you immediately turned away from their obvious drunken flirtyness and paid attention to adoring children, not offering the ladies a second glance after signing their hat. THATS CLASS and why you are our super hero.

    No into yourself at all.

    Go Soxman Go!

  20. Soxman in Minnesota? Woo hoo! You truly are the man! Crush those Twinkies!

  21. paulmbanks says

    After tonight, Soxman was right and I was wrong- the bullpen is a major concern, Jenks has an ERA of 7 this month.

Speak Your Mind